Last season's Singapore Idol was pretty decent TV fare and I thought the winner was ok. This season just makes me cringe. I managed to watch most of the 4 piano shows and even the results shows. Its so easy to pick out those going through, given the poor quality of singing across the board. Even the decent ones weren't great. Some were so awful I turned the TV off. At times, I felt tormented and hung on just to hear some vindication from the judges. I wanted to make sure it wasn't just my TV or my ears playing tricks on me.
The results shows are horrible as well. I watched 2, whilst waiting for the World Cup to start. Recycling the same songs and having two hosts desperately trying to squeeze out suspense like water from a grain of sand. And why do we even need an extra, squeaky host?
Perhaps the poor singing has to do with the youth and nerves of the participants but the bland "lines" they say before and after performances make me think about the rigidity of Singapore's education system. I feel like they spent more time rehearsing how to say "And I hope you'll vote for me, Singapore!" (cue big smile, wink, waves) in front of a mirror than practising their singing. There were a few retorts though. But, saying things like "I don't suck dammit!" just comes off rude when in fact they do suck. As much as vacuum cleaners in fact.
I don't profess to be some expert singing coach or whatever. I was in a choir before so I know what singing is like and how difficult it can be. I also don't expect the wannabes to be amazing knock your socks off singers. I merely expect them to be half decent. If you counted the number of flat notes there were, you could level Bukit Timah. And despite the fact most of them are so young and are styled relatively fashionably, the music on offer really sounded old fashioned and boring.
I think I'd be somewhat embarrased by this season's quality if I were a judge or organiser. I think I'd have skipped to the top 4 and not waste time, weed out the rest. Like Ken Lim put it to the bunch coming back for the wildcard show, "some of you are only here for the numbers".
I'd rather have Careless Whisperer as one of the "top" 12 because its about the same. Watch if you're into teen dramas, although I think other crappy productions on channel 5 might be better in that department.
Its a pity. We've got people like Stefanie, Tanya et al flying the flag and most bands in Singapore may not have amazing singers but musically, they're competent to say the least. I don't feel like washing my head after listening to them. So I'm just sad, as a music lover, to see that this is the best we can come up with in a singing competition I don't expect much of. Sing-a-poor iDull.